Self-Judgment and the Compassion of God ["The Here and Now" from HCC]


THE HERE & NOW NEWSLETTER

FROM HARBOR CHRISTIAN COUNSELING :: AUGUST 2026 EDITION

“I’m embarrassed to say this, but I feel..”

It’s not easy to open up. Many of us approach counseling, and reaching out for help in general, with ambivalence. We want to feel better and know that talking can help, but the act of expressing vulnerable feelings is uncomfortable. Right as we’re on the precipice of diving into raw emotion, we can get cold feet. There are many ways to avoid taking this plunge, but one that often presents itself: instead of feeling our feelings, we become their judge.

It can be easy to intellectualize conversations and speak about feelings from a distance. Instead of letting raw emotion come to the surface, we catch it at a distance and judge it.

“It’s silly to admit this... It’s stupid to feel this way... I know this sounds dumb and makes me a bad Christian...”

Easier than owning and embodying vulnerable emotions such as fear, sadness, loneliness and shame, we self-criticize and deliver a guilty verdict. This can feel safer and give us a sense of control. We think that if we can pronounce moral judgment on ourselves it might be counted as virtuous and atone for our failures.

The problem is these judgments lead to a conversational dead end and don’t allow for the possibility of growth. Beating ourselves up only leads to striving and doesn’t motivate sustainable change. What takes courage is to welcome those feelings: to lean into the young, messy, fearful parts of ourselves. By giving voice to our emotional experience with a safe listener, we not only find words for what we’re feeling - we also find we don’t have to feel it alone.

In Christian discourse we often hear of the importance of being “born again” and that we must “become like children to enter the Kingdom of God.” But maybe less discussed is the process of “growing in Christ,” to which the authors of the New Testament consistently refer. Starting as a spiritual infant (in Greek: nepios) and growing up into a mature adult (in Greek: teleios), the clear expectation is that we all start as babies and have a lot of growing up to do! This permission to learn— to not have everything all figured out—is crucial to growing in our emotional life as well.

It can be easy to associate a harsh inner critic with the voice of God. But it’s recorded 12 times in the Gospels that Jesus was “moved with compassion” towards those in need. Consider: what does a compassionate God sound like, and how might it feel to receive his care? The heart posture of God himself shows us how we might approach our own vulnerability.

By welcoming it with openness and curiosity, we notice how our body is experiencing sadness, fear, or longing and say what it feels like. Words are powerful containers of emotion, and the act of naming feelings helps metabolize the emotion. We finally get in touch with what we need, and in those moments can allow God to actively father us. This experience of God meeting us with compassion and understanding leads us through difficulty and into growth.

Written by: Aaron Jones, LICSW (Senior Clinician)


Check out some of these recent posts from the HCC team on our Instagram account on self-talk. Be sure to follow us there for more exclusive content being released weekly.


Harbor is Growing! Two New Locations Now Open!

Just over nine years ago, Harbor launched in Boston with the aim of serving the city and its near neighbors. Since then, the Harbor team and the clients we serve have spread out significantly. So we are excited to announce that Harbor is opening two new locations with the aim of making biblically informed, gospel driven, clinically skilled counseling available to people across Eastern Massachusetts.

In late July, we opened our second location on CAPE COD in Hyannis. And on September 1st, we will be opening a third location - METRO NORTH - located in Woburn and conveniently accessible to anyone north of Boston. And, of course, our original location in BOSTON is still going strong!

Each site will have the same heart, same mission, same quality of care - just more places to find it!

Even as we add new in-person options, TELEHEALTH care remains a core part of our service model at Harbor. Our most widely accessible option continues to be our “virtual office” where our team provides safe, secure, and effective telehealth services that allow you to connect with your provider from wherever you are located.


Your financial support makes this monthly newsletter and all of our other resourcing and scholarship programs happen. Please consider partnering with us through a one-time gift or monthly donation to support the mission of HCC.

The Here and Now Newsletter :: Wisdom for Navigating Life's Challenges

Harbor Christian Counseling, 874 Beacon Street, Boston, MA 02215
Unsubscribe · Preferences

Matt Warren

Read more from Matt Warren

THE HERE & NOW NEWSLETTER FROM HARBOR CHRISTIAN COUNSELING :: JULY 2026 EDITION Often in the counseling office, I find that we as Christians can regard the word ‘assertive’ as a negative trait. For some people it seems to contradict an idea of meekness or gentleness. I often hear the phrase ‘turn the other cheek’ used as an example of a teaching that contradicts assertiveness as a Christlike characteristic. However, assertiveness is the. Here’s why: Click to view larger and/or download PDF...

THE HERE & NOW NEWSLETTER FROM HARBOR CHRISTIAN COUNSELING :: JUNE 2026 EDITION Perfectionism is one of those mental health terms that people throw around all too casually and even use as a badge of honor. “Ugh, I’m such a perfectionist,” he says, as he secretly hopes everyone notices and admires his attention to detail, exactitude, and overall standard of excellence (I may or may not be speaking from experience here…). And yet, for those who know the real struggle involved with it,...

THE HERE & NOW NEWSLETTER FROM HARBOR CHRISTIAN COUNSELING :: MAY 2026 EDITION How do you spend your mornings and evenings? Do you find yourself connecting with loved ones or spending time on a hobby? Or do you find yourself reaching for your phone and before you know it, you’ve spent hours scrolling from one video or article to the next? If this is you, you’re engaging in what is known as “doomscrolling,” and you are not alone. Doomscrolling and information overload have become the “new...